Ultra-Processed Foods and Insulin: Does Processing Matter?

A new 2026 study found that an ultra-processed meal produced a greater insulin response than a nutritionally matched, less-processed meal, despite similar overall blood glucose responses over three hours.
The findings suggest that food processing may influence how the body handles nutrients beyond what appears on a nutrition label.
However, a higher insulin response after one meal does not prove insulin resistance, weight gain or an increased risk of diabetes. For everyday health, overall dietary quality, eating patterns and individual nutritional needs remain more important than avoiding every processed food.
Two meals can contain almost identical amounts of energy, carbohydrate, protein, fat and fibre, yet produce different responses inside the body.
That is the central finding of a randomised study published in Nature Metabolism in October 2026. Researchers found that healthy adults released more insulin after eating an ultra-processed meal than after eating a carefully matched less-processed meal. [1]
But what does this mean for your blood sugar, metabolic health and everyday food choices?
The answer is more nuanced than simply avoiding processed foods.
What Did the 2026 Study Find About Ultra-Processed Foods and Insulin?
The researchers investigated whether the degree of food processing could affect metabolism independently of the nutrients normally listed on food labels.
The study included 57 healthy-weight adults aged 18–45 years. Of these, 32 completed both metabolic meal-testing sessions.
Participants consumed two different meals on separate mornings, with the order randomly assigned.
Meal 1: Less-processed foods
The meal contained foods such as eggs, banana and cheese.
Meal 2: Ultra-processed foods
The meal included foods such as a peanut butter and jam sandwich, a biscuit and vegetable chips.
Both meals provided approximately 300 calories (1,255 kilojoules).
Importantly, they were closely matched for:
Total energy and meal weight
Carbohydrate, protein and fat
Dietary fibre
Sodium and water
Glycaemic index and glycaemic load
Differences across the matched nutritional measures were no greater than approximately 1.6%.
Participants finished each meal within 10 minutes while researchers monitored their metabolism and collected blood samples over the following three hours. [1]
Finding 1: Overall Blood Glucose Responses Were Similar
The two meals produced similar total blood glucose exposure over three hours.
Blood glucose rose more rapidly after the less-processed meal, with a higher reading at 20 minutes.
However, the overall glucose response, measured as the area under the blood glucose curve, was not significantly different between meals.
This is an important distinction.
The glucose responses were not identical at every moment, but their total measured exposure over the three-hour period was similar.
Finding 2: Insulin Was Higher After the Ultra-Processed Meal
Despite similar overall blood glucose responses, insulin concentrations were significantly higher after the ultra-processed meal at:
40 minutes
60 minutes
90 minutes
120 minutes
Total insulin exposure over three hours was also significantly greater.
Insulin measurements were available for 31 participants in the metabolic analysis. [1]
Why does this matter?
Insulin is a hormone produced by the pancreas. It helps glucose move from the bloodstream into cells and plays an important role in energy storage and metabolism.
Insulin normally increases after eating, particularly after meals containing carbohydrate.
The study suggests that the body may sometimes need, or produce, a different insulin response when processing changes the characteristics of a meal, even if its measured nutritional composition is very similar.
However, the researchers could not establish exactly why the insulin response differed.
Finding 3: The Body Used Fuels Differently
The researchers also found differences in how participants used energy after eating.
Compared with the less-processed meal, the ultra-processed meal was associated with:
A modestly higher post-meal energy expenditure
Greater fat oxidation, meaning more fat was used as fuel during the measurement period
A smaller increase in carbohydrate oxidation
The broader study also used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to examine responses to pictures of food.
Differences in carbohydrate metabolism were associated with activity in brain regions involved in processing food-related cues and reward.
However, these brain measurements were collected in separate research sessions. They do not demonstrate that the test meals directly caused changes in cravings or future eating behaviour.
Participants also did not report significant differences in meal liking, hunger or fullness between the two test meals. [1]
The key finding: Nutritionally similar meals can produce different short-term metabolic responses. Whether those differences translate into meaningful long-term health outcomes remains uncertain.
Does a Higher Insulin Response Mean the Meal Is Unhealthy?
Not necessarily.
A higher insulin response after a meal is not automatically evidence of poor metabolic health.
Insulin is essential for normal glucose regulation. The amount released after eating can be influenced by many factors, including the type of carbohydrate, protein sources, digestion and individual physiology.
An important distinction is the difference between an acute insulin response and insulin resistance.
An acute response describes what happens to insulin concentrations after eating.
Insulin resistance refers to a reduced response of body tissues to insulin. It is a more complex metabolic condition that cannot be diagnosed from one meal response.
The 2026 study did not establish that the participants developed insulin resistance or that the higher insulin response caused harm.
It also did not measure whether repeatedly consuming the tested meals would increase diabetes risk or change body weight over time.
The study was relatively small, involved young healthy-weight adults and examined only one approximately 300-calorie meal of each type.
Furthermore, although total protein was matched, the meals contained different protein sources. The ultra-processed meal also contained more additives, and the researchers did not directly measure differences in food structure.
Consequently, the trial cannot determine which specific aspect of processing produced the different insulin response. [1]
This makes the study scientifically interesting, but not a reason to fear normal changes in insulin after eating.
What Does the Wider Research Tell Us About Ultra-Processed Foods?
The new findings become more meaningful when considered alongside larger studies.
Ultra-Processed Foods and Type 2 Diabetes Risk
A major umbrella review published in The BMJ in 2024 examined research involving almost 10 million participants.
It found that greater consumption of ultra-processed foods was associated with several adverse health outcomes, including a higher risk of developing type 2 diabetes. [2]
The review reported convincing epidemiological evidence for the association with type 2 diabetes, although the certainty of individual findings varied.
Importantly, an association does not prove that ultra-processing itself causes diabetes.
People who consume more ultra-processed foods may also differ in overall dietary quality, physical activity, lifestyle and other factors that influence health.
The evidence supports paying attention to dietary patterns, but it does not identify one specific metabolic mechanism as responsible for the observed risks.
Ultra-Processed Foods May Encourage Higher Energy Intake
A controlled feeding study published by Hall and colleagues in Cell Metabolism in 2019 provides another important piece of evidence.
Twenty adults lived in a research facility and consumed either an ultra-processed or an unprocessed diet for two weeks before switching to the other diet.
The diets were designed to provide comparable nutritional composition, but participants could eat as much or as little of the available food as they wanted.
During the ultra-processed diet, participants consumed approximately 508 additional calories per day, on average.
Over the two-week period, participants gained approximately 0.9 kg during the ultra-processed diet and lost approximately 0.9 kg during the unprocessed diet. [3]
This demonstrated that the ultra-processed dietary pattern encouraged greater spontaneous energy intake in that controlled setting.
It does not mean that every ultra-processed food causes overeating or that everyone will consume an additional 500 calories daily.
Nevertheless, the experiment provides stronger evidence for the importance of food choices and eating behaviour than simply focusing on an isolated insulin measurement.
Does Higher Insulin Automatically Cause Greater Fat Gain?
The relationship between insulin, energy balance and body weight is complex.
A 2017 review by Hall and Guo examined 32 controlled feeding studies comparing diets containing different proportions of carbohydrate and fat while maintaining similar calorie and protein intakes.
The analysis did not find that lowering carbohydrate to reduce insulin produced greater body-fat loss under equal-calorie conditions. The pooled results showed small differences favouring lower-fat diets. [4]
This challenges the simplistic idea that a higher post-meal insulin response automatically leads to greater fat gain.
Body weight and body composition are influenced by long-term energy balance, appetite regulation, physical activity, physiology, medication and other individual factors.
Insulin matters for metabolism, but one insulin response does not determine long-term weight or health outcomes.
What Are Ultra-Processed Foods, and Should You Avoid Them?
Ultra-processed foods are commonly defined using the NOVA classification system, which groups foods according to the nature and purpose of their processing.
Ultra-processed products often contain industrially formulated ingredients, such as modified starches, flavourings, emulsifiers or other additives not typically used in home cooking.
Examples may include certain packaged snack foods, confectionery, sweetened drinks, instant meals and some commercially manufactured breads or cereals.
However, processing is not automatically harmful.
Freezing vegetables, pasteurising milk, cooking legumes and preparing canned foods can improve food safety, convenience and accessibility.
Even within the ultra-processed category, products differ substantially in nutritional value.
For example, a fibre-rich wholegrain breakfast cereal and a sugar-sweetened soft drink should not be treated as nutritionally equivalent simply because both may fall within the same processing category.
Food Standards Australia New Zealand recognises that overall diet quality remains important when evaluating the health implications of processed foods. [5]
The Australian Dietary Guidelines recommend choosing a variety of nutritious foods from the five food groups while limiting discretionary foods that are high in saturated fat, added sugars or added salt. [6]
The practical message is therefore not to eliminate every packaged food.
It is to consider what a food contributes to your overall eating pattern.
How Can You Apply These Findings to Everyday Eating?
You do not need to calculate your insulin response after every meal or follow an extreme diet to make beneficial food choices.
A more useful approach is to focus on nutritional quality, meal satisfaction and sustainable habits.
1. Build Meals Around Nutritious Foods
Where practical, include a variety of vegetables, fruit, legumes, wholegrains, nuts, seeds and suitable protein foods.
For example, breakfast could include plain oats topped with yoghurt, fruit and nuts.
Lunch could be a wholegrain sandwich with egg, tuna, tofu or another preferred protein, alongside salad vegetables.
These choices can provide fibre, protein and a range of micronutrients without requiring complicated meal rules.
2. Look Beyond Calories on Food Labels
Two products with similar calories may differ substantially in fibre, micronutrients, added sugars, sodium and overall nutritional quality.
When comparing packaged foods, consider:
Fibre content
Protein and overall nutrient contribution
Added sugars and sodium
Saturated fat
Portion size
How the food fits into your usual eating pattern
A nutrition label remains useful. The new research simply highlights that it cannot describe every aspect of how a food behaves during digestion and metabolism.
3. Make Practical Swaps Rather Than Imposing Food Bans
Small changes are often easier to maintain than complete dietary overhauls.
For example:
Replace some sweetened drinks with water.
Include fruit, yoghurt or nuts as convenient snack options.
Use frozen vegetables and canned legumes to prepare quick meals.
Choose fibre-rich wholegrain options more often.
Reduce reliance on energy-dense snack foods when they frequently replace balanced meals.
There is no need to avoid nutritious convenience foods simply because they have undergone processing.
For additional practical strategies, FerFit's 7 Metabolic Health Habits to Support Energy and Blood Sugar explores sustainable eating and lifestyle choices.
The aim is a flexible, nutritionally adequate eating pattern rather than a perfectly unprocessed diet.
When Should You Seek Professional Nutrition Advice?
The new research is interesting, but it should not be used as a self-diagnostic test for insulin resistance or diabetes.
If you are concerned about your diabetes risk, blood glucose levels or possible insulin resistance, your GP can assess your medical history, risk factors and whether investigations such as HbA1c or blood glucose testing are appropriate.
An Accredited Practising Dietitian can provide individualised nutrition assessment and dietary management.
At FerFit Dietetics & Nutrition, dietetic support can include reviewing your current eating pattern, nutrient intake, food preferences, relevant medical information and practical barriers to dietary change.
Recommendations may need to be adapted for people living with diabetes, pregnancy, kidney disease, eating disorders or other medical conditions.
If you use insulin or medication that can cause hypoglycaemia, significant carbohydrate changes should be coordinated with your diabetes care team. Do not change prescribed medication based on this study.
For people with a history of restrictive eating or food-related anxiety, maintaining adequate nutrition and a flexible relationship with food is particularly important.
Learn more about FerFit's metabolic health dietitian service or seek personalised advice through a consultation. (Book here)
The Bottom Line: Food Processing Matters, but Context Matters More
The 2026 Nature Metabolism study found that two carefully matched meals could produce similar overall blood glucose responses while triggering different insulin and energy-use responses.
It adds to growing evidence that a food's physical characteristics and processing may influence digestion and metabolism in ways not fully captured by conventional nutrition information.
However, the study does not show that a higher insulin response to one ultra-processed meal causes insulin resistance, weight gain or diabetes.
The wider human evidence supports a practical approach: prioritise a varied, nutrient-rich dietary pattern, be mindful of frequent reliance on discretionary ultra-processed foods, and make changes that are sustainable for your circumstances.
You do not need a perfectly unprocessed diet to support your metabolic health.
Personalised Metabolic Nutrition Support
If you are finding it difficult to navigate conflicting advice about carbohydrates, insulin, processed foods or metabolic health, FerFit Dietetics & Nutrition offers individualised nutrition support with Accredited Practising Dietitians in Melbourne and via telehealth.
A dietitian can help you understand your overall eating pattern and develop practical, evidence-based strategies suited to your health needs.
This article provides general nutrition education and does not replace medical assessment, diagnosis or individualised treatment.
References
Hutelin Z, Ahrens M, Baugh ME, Nartey E, Herald DL 3rd, Hanlon AL, et al. Metabolic and neural responses to ultraprocessed foods: a randomized, controlled, crossover study. Nat Metab. 2026;8(10):2152–2164. doi:10.1038/s42255-026-01619-4.
Lane MM, Gamage E, Du S, Ashtree DN, McGuinness AJ, Gauci S, et al. Ultra-processed food exposure and adverse health outcomes: umbrella review of epidemiological meta-analyses. BMJ. 2024;384. doi:10.1136/bmj-2023-077310.
Hall KD, Ayuketah A, Brychta R, Cai H, Cassimatis T, Chen KY, et al. Ultra-processed diets cause excess calorie intake and weight gain: an inpatient randomized controlled trial of ad libitum food intake. Cell Metab. 2019;30(1):67–77.e3. doi:10.1016/j.cmet.2019.05.008.
Hall KD, Guo J. Obesity energetics: body weight regulation and the effects of diet composition. Gastroenterology. 2017;152(7):1718–1727.e3.
Food Standards Australia New Zealand. Diet quality and processed foods. Australian Government. Accessed 3 November 2026.
National Health and Medical Research Council. Australian Dietary Guidelines. Canberra: NHMRC; 2013.






Comments